Introduction
Since the outbreak of war on April 15, 2023, between the Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF) and the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), Sudan has entered an unprecedented phase of violence. Human rights violations have escalated, including widespread arbitrary detention and enforced disappearances. These abuses have not only targeted ordinary civilians but have also extended to political activists, journalists, and human rights defenders.
This research aims to shed light on the phenomenon of enforced disappearance by analyzing the responsible parties, the targeted groups, and the geographical distribution of detention and abduction incidents.
Background
Sudan has a long history of enforced disappearances, a practice used as a tool of repression under the regime of Omar al-Bashir. His security apparatus systematically carried out these violations to silence political opponents and intimidate activists.
With al-Bashir’s overthrow in 2019, there was hope that such abuses would end—especially after Sudan ratified the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance in 2021. This commitment signaled the country’s intent to combat enforced disappearances and uphold human rights. Under the convention, Sudan is obligated to search for disappeared persons, investigate cases, prosecute perpetrators, and provide assistance and compensation to victims and their families.
However, these hopes were short-lived. The recent war between the SAF and RSF has led to a resurgence of enforced disappearances as a systematic tool in armed conflict.
What Is Enforced Disappearance?
According to Article 2 of the Convention, enforced disappearance is defined as:
“The arrest, detention, abduction or any other form of deprivation of liberty by agents of the State or by persons or groups of persons acting with the authorization, support or acquiescence of the State, followed by a refusal to acknowledge the deprivation of liberty or by concealment of the fate or whereabouts of the disappeared person, which place such a person outside the protection of the law.”
Enforced disappearance constitutes a dual violation of human rights. On one hand, victims are subjected to cruel and inhumane treatment, including torture and detention in degrading conditions. On the other hand, families endure profound psychological and social suffering, uncertain of their loved ones’ fate—left to wonder whether they are alive or dead.
Enforced Disappearance and Arbitrary Detention: Defining the Terms in This Study
While this research adopts the official definition of enforced disappearance as outlined in the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance, the research team recognizes that this definition does not fully capture the complexities of the Sudanese context. The convention primarily defines enforced disappearance as acts committed by state agents or individuals acting with the state’s authorization or acquiescence. However, in Sudan, enforced disappearance manifests in two distinct forms: one perpetrated by state authorities and another by armed groups operating beyond state control.
To address these distinctions and ensure clarity in categorizing the different forms of enforced disappearance in Sudan, the research team applied the Insights methodology, classifying cases into two primary categories:
- State-Enforced Detention
This category refers to the arrest and detention of individuals through force or the threat of force, typically under the pretext of criminal suspicion or political opposition. Such detentions are carried out by state institutions, including the SAF, security services, and other government-affiliated entities operating under the state’s authority. - Abduction/Capture
This refers to the forcible seizure of individuals by military forces or armed groups acting outside the framework of the state. This includes groups such as the RSF and other armed factions, including those signatories to the Juba Peace Agreement (JPA) or are part of the Darfur Joint Force (DJF), regardless of whether they are aligned with the government.
Key Differences Between State Detention and Abduction
While both enforced detention and abduction fall under the broader category of enforced disappearance, their key distinction lies in the identity of the perpetrator. State-enforced detention is carried out by government actors and reflects the use of official authority. Abduction, on the other hand, signifies the absence of state control and the influence of non-state armed factions operating outside legal frameworks.
This classification provides a more precise framework for analyzing enforced disappearances in Sudan. By linking each incident to the responsible actor, the research methodology enhances the assessment of human rights violations and their broader implications.
Challenges in Investigating Enforced Disappearances in Sudan
The ongoing conflict in Sudan presents the greatest obstacle to investigating enforced disappearances, as it has led to widespread insecurity and the breakdown of law enforcement in many regions. This deterioration has made it increasingly difficult to identify detention locations or obtain reliable information about missing individuals.
While challenges in accessing information about detainees existed before the conflict, limited details on detention sites and the condition of detainees were sometimes available. However, as security structures in SAF-controlled areas weaken, arrests have become increasingly arbitrary, often at the discretion of military officials or mobilized personnel—particularly at checkpoints during travel within or between states. In areas under RSF control, the complete absence of judicial institutions has worsened the situation. Although efforts have been made to establish judicial bodies in some regions, such as Darfur and al-Jazeera, these newly formed institutions remain ineffective in enforcing clear legal protocols for arrests. This legal vacuum has left detentions largely unchecked, creating conditions for ethnic-based targeting and abuse.
Additionally, the absence of security and judicial oversight has removed any safeguards protecting detainees’ rights, leading to widespread torture and ill-treatment. The escalation of hostilities around prisons and detention facilities—particularly in the early stages of the conflict—further complicated the situation. Many detainees were released, while others were secretly relocated, making it even more difficult to track their whereabouts. Furthermore, numerous regions suffer from a lack of due process, where detentions occur without official registration, legal representation, or fair trials, exacerbating Sudan’s human rights crisis.
- Incommunicado Detention and the Use of Secret Detention Facilities
Many individuals are detained without access to their families or legal representation. Detaining authorities frequently deny involvement, making it nearly impossible to verify cases of disappearance. Perpetrators also rely on secret or makeshift detention sites to avoid accountability. These locations remain unknown even to survivors upon release, making it extremely difficult to trace detainees or gather evidence regarding their conditions.
- Challenges in Documentation and Targeting of Human Rights Defenders
Enforced disappearances are often carried out covertly and in the context of military operations, making them inherently difficult to document. Additionally, communication blackouts, including internet shutdowns, hinder human rights organizations from collecting data from affected areas.
Human rights defenders face intimidation, harassment, and threats for documenting violations, deterring them from reporting cases of enforced disappearance. Survivors also risk arrest or torture if they testify, further complicating efforts to gather reliable information.
Moreover, some detentions—particularly those carried out by the RSF—are motivated by ransom demands, where captors contact families directly. Fear of retaliation prevents many families from reporting these cases, as they worry that speaking out could lead to further harm or even the execution of detainees. Survivors have also reported instances of collective punishment in response to sharing information. As a result, official records of enforced disappearances significantly underrepresent the true scale of the crisis, creating a major gap in available data.
- Restricted Access to Detention Sites
Independent investigators and international monitors are systematically denied access to detention facilities, preventing them from verifying detainees’ conditions. The lack of transparency surrounding these sites makes it nearly impossible to track detainees or ensure their safety.
Timeline Analysis of Enforced Detentions and Abductions
Figure (1): Trends in Enforced Detention and Abduction (January – October 2024)
This figure illustrates the number of enforced detention and abduction incidents in Sudan between January and October 2024, highlighting the significant disparity between the two in both scale and frequency. It also reveals temporal variations, with enforced detention remaining relatively stable throughout the conflict, while abductions surged during specific periods. This trend underscores the widespread use of abduction as a method of abuse, with the RSF emerging as the primary perpetrators.
Map (1): Geographic Distribution of Enforced Detention and Abduction
Patterns of Enforced Detention
Between January and October 2024, 99 individuals were subjected to enforced detention across 37 separate incidents in 11 states. These figures reflect the widespread use of arbitrary detention by various government agencies as a mechanism for exerting security and political control. The following section provides a detailed analysis of these incidents, examining the responsible parties, targeted groups, geographic distribution, and underlying motives.
SAF’s Role in Enforced Detention
Figure (2): The SAF’s Responsibility for Enforced Detention
The data indicate that the SAF were the primary entity responsible for enforced detention during this period, carrying out 22 incidents, involving 64 individuals—the highest number among government agencies. This pattern reflects the SAF’s systematic use of arbitrary detention as a tool for political and security control.
Targeted Groups and Justifications for Enforced Detention
An analysis of the targeted groups shows that civilians—those not detained on the basis of political affiliation or activity—were the most affected, accounting for 65.6% of all enforced detentions conducted by the SAF. This pattern suggests a broad targeting of civilians under security pretexts, with the SAF frequently justifying these detentions as “preventive measures.” The SAF has relied on these claims to carry out arbitrary detentions, often citing suspected collaboration with the RSF as a justification.
Beyond civilians, the data indicate that the SAF also targeted members of resistance committees and political parties, as part of a broader crackdown on opposition movements. Additionally, detentions included religious figures, such as the leader of a Sufi group, following the SAF’s recapture of Beit al-Mal area from the RSF.
Patterns of SAF Enforced Detention
The September 2024 report, Serious human rights violations perpetrated in the context of mass civilian detention in Sudan, documented a clear pattern in SAF’s use of enforced detention. These detentions are often carried out as a preventive measure, frequently justified by suspicions of RSF affiliation.
While enforced detention has remained a consistent practice throughout the conflict, the aforementioned report suggests that the direct correlation between major RSF attacks and SAF detentions has become less evident. This shift reflects the evolving nature of SAF’s military operations and its increasing use of detention as a strategic tool of war.
Other reports highlight that SAF frequently uses preventive detention to suppress political actors and members of resistance committees, often on charges of “affiliation with RSF.” This accusation has become a primary justification for detention, as regular forces now consider any perceived lack of support for the war as grounds for detention.
Several detainees have reported being held in overcrowded cells, suggesting that official figures underrepresent the actual number of individuals subjected to SAF’s enforced detention. In addition, detainees have described various forms of abuse by SAF personnel during their detention.
One detainee, a member of the Services and Change Committees in Omdurman, shared his testimony in a March 2024 statement published by alHurra:
“We were subjected to severe abuse, and SAF personnel referred to us as ‘Janjaweed.’ They often forced us to remain in the scorching sun for hours.”
The use of terms like “Janjaweed” by SAF personnel reflects preconceived notions about detainees, leading to their mistreatment without any real evidence of wrongdoing.
These preconceived biases often escalate into severe mistreatment. The same detainee further reported:
“They would deprive us of meals for up to two days, leaving many detainees unable to stand or walk, before we were released without warning—after being forced to sign a pledge not to cooperate with RSF.”
Such practices represent serious violations of detainees’ rights and constitute a flagrant breach of both international and Sudanese law, which strictly prohibit torture and ill-treatment—even after a detainee has been convicted. With the collapse of Sudan’s justice system, such abuses have become more widespread and occur without accountability, highlighting the dire conditions detainees face in the ongoing conflict.
The Racial and Ethnic Dimension of SAF Targeting
The report noted that since the outbreak of the war, a clear racial and ethnic dimension has emerged in the targeting operations carried out by the SAF. These operations have primarily focused on individuals of Kordofan or Darfuri origin, particularly those from so-called “Arab” tribes such as the Rizeigat and Misseriya. This targeting has often followed RSF attacks, with the SAF justifying arrests based on suspected affiliation with or support for the RSF.
This pattern reflects the “politicization of ideological values associated with ethnic and religious identity” in Sudan. The RSF’s reliance on ethnic-based recruitment, drawing primarily from Arab communities in Darfur, has further reinforced the ethnic dimension of the conflict.
As the conflict has intensified, the targeting of individuals based on ethnic identity has significantly expanded. Many detainees are accused of supporting the RSF without any tangible evidence, with arrests often based on loose social connections—such as having a friend or relative linked to the forces—resulting in arbitrary detentions.
States Most Affected by Enforced Detention
Figure (3) illustrates the number of enforced detentions recorded in each state during the research period
Detailed Analysis of Abductions/Captures
Between January and October 2024, a total of 712 individuals were subjected to abductions/captures across 96 incidents in 12 states. These figures highlight the widespread nature of these violations, underscoring the deteriorating security situation and the exploitation of the power vacuum by armed groups—particularly the RSF—to further their objectives.
RSF’s Responsibility for Abductions/Captures
Figure (4)
The figure demonstrates that the RSF was the primary perpetrator of abductions/captures during the research period. RSF forces were responsible for 83 incidents, affecting 712 individuals, accounting for 92.2% of all documented cases. This pattern indicates the RSF’s systematic use of abductions/captures as a tool for political and security control, as well as for instilling fear within local communities.
An analysis of the targeted groups reveals that civilians—individuals abducted without political affiliation—were the most affected, comprising 75.6% of total victims. This trend suggests that the RSF’s abduction/capture operations were not random but rather part of a broader strategy aimed at consolidating influence and destabilizing communities in conflict-affected areas.
Beyond civilians, the RSF also targeted political figures, activists, and specific professional groups. A notable example was the abduction of a tribal leader in al-Obeid outskirts, North Kordofan, following an RSF raid on the area. This incident underscores the RSF’s practice of targeting influential community figures as part of its broader campaign of systematic abductions/captures.
Analysis of the Distribution of Abduction/Capture Cases by State
Figure (5) displays the number of individuals subjected to abduction/capture incidents across different states during the research period
Patterns Associated with RSF Abduction/Capture Incidents
The report identifies two primary patterns in the RSF’s use of abductions/captures:
- Organized and Simultaneous Waves of Abductions
The RSF systematically carries out organized and simultaneous abductions, with incidents escalating significantly during or immediately following major offensives. These waves primarily target civilians based on ethnic or social affiliations, reflecting a deliberate and discriminatory policy.
The coordination of these abductions across multiple states suggests a centralized strategy developed by senior RSF officials, with local unit commanders overseeing its execution. This level of organization underscores the systematic nature of these violations.
- Abductions Following Territorial Control
The report indicates that the RSF systematically conducts large-scale abductions immediately after seizing control of new areas. These incidents are typically carried out by officers or small units of RSF personnel.
One of the primary objectives of these violations is looting and extortion, using detention as a tool to assert control over local resources or coerce victims into paying ransom. Testimonies indicate that this pattern is widespread in areas experiencing instability, further exacerbating the suffering of local communities.
Additionally, the RSF employs these abductions as a means of forced recruitment, compelling individuals—particularly young men—to join its ranks. This practice strengthens the RSF’s military capacity and ensures the continuity of its operations in controlled territories.
Another documented violation associated with these abductions is conflict-related sexual violence, deployed as a means to instill fear within communities. Numerous cases of systematic sexual violence inside detention facilities and during abductions have been reported.
Finally, these abductions serve as a tool for social control, intimidating communities to entrench RSF dominance in captured areas. By fostering an atmosphere of fear, the RSF seeks to suppress resistance and impose its authority.
These patterns confirm that abductions following territorial control are not isolated incidents but part of a systematic strategy designed to achieve military, economic, and social objectives at the expense of fundamental human rights.
Discriminatory Violence and Targeted Abductions by the RSF
The RSF has systematically used abductions as a means of enacting discriminatory violence against specific ethnic groups. These practices reflect the ethnic and social dimensions of the conflict, where targeted communities face intimidation and marginalization to weaken their influence within local society.
The report documents widespread and systematic RSF-led abductions of “non-Arab” groups, particularly in Darfur and Kordofan states, where attacks against the Masalit and other communities have escalated to levels increasingly regarded as crimes against humanity and genocide (see Figure [5]).
A key feature of these violations is the targeted abduction and mistreatment of individuals from “non-Arab” tribes, including the Masalit, Fur, Zaghawa, and Tunjur. The RSF has focused on prominent figures within these communities, particularly those who have publicly condemned RSF actions.
In South Kordofan, the Nuba people have been a primary target, largely due to their perceived affiliation with the Sudan People’s Liberation Movement, Abdelaziz al-Hilu faction (SPLM/al-Hilu).
These patterns confirm that ethnic discrimination is a core strategy within the RSF’s military operations, reinforcing the broader dynamics of persecution and suppression in conflict-affected areas.
Conclusion
This report highlights systematic patterns of serious violations committed by the conflicting parties since the outbreak of the crisis in April 2023, with enforced detention and abductions used as primary tools for intimidation, coercion, and control. The analysis demonstrates that these practices are not isolated but rather part of deliberate strategies targeting specific groups based on ethnic, social, and political affiliations, exacerbating sectarian divisions and worsening the humanitarian crisis.
The findings underscore the intersection of military operations with broader political and social objectives, where violations serve as mechanisms for oppression and resource exploitation. The breakdown of Sudan’s justice system has further enabled these violations, reinforcing a climate of impunity that leaves civilians increasingly vulnerable. The impact extends beyond individuals, affecting entire communities by creating an environment of fear, persecution, and systemic discrimination.
We emphasize the urgent need for coordinated efforts to halt these violations and ensure accountability. This requires strengthening monitoring and documentation mechanisms, while working towards the establishment of a domestic legal framework capable of delivering justice and redress for victims. A comprehensive response—integrating political, legal, and humanitarian measures—is essential to protect civilians, restore stability, and rebuild Sudan’s social fabric.


