Nature and Patterns of Violations Against Civilians

This is the first part of a joint study conducted by INSIGHTS and Hiwarat Jeel at-Thawra, aimed at providing a comprehensive and accurate analysis of the violations committed by the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) against civilians in Sudan during the first year of the April 15, 2023 war between the Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF) and the RSF.

This section focuses on documenting the scale and nature of these violations and examining their impact on the lives of affected individuals and communities. Specifically, it seeks to identify key patterns of violations, assess their effects on the living conditions of the population, and explore the humanitarian dimensions of the ongoing conflict. In contrast, the second part of the research, to be published separately, will analyze the political and economic motivations behind these violations, their role in intensifying the conflict and the humanitarian crisis, and the involvement of external actors supporting the RSF. This will provide a more holistic understanding of the influence of regional and international dynamics on these violations.

This collaboration between INSIGHTS and Hiwarat Jeel at-Thawra reflects a strong commitment to providing objective, evidence-based analysis. We would like to extend our gratitude to all those who contributed to the data collection and analysis, as well as to those who provided the intellectual and logistical support necessary to complete this research.

Introduction

In April 2023, a war broke out between the SAF, which represents the legitimate and constitutional army of the country, and the RSF, a paramilitary group originally established by the Sudanese government in 2017 under the regime of Omer al-Bashir. The war followed a period of intense political and economic rivalry between the two factions, marked by deep divisions over security and military reforms, including the integration of the RSF into the national army. Both sides blame each other for initiating the conflict: the SAF accuses the RSF of attempting to overthrow the Commander-in-Chief of the SAF, Abd al-Fattah al-Burhan, and seize power; while the RSF alleges that Islamist factions within the SAF instigated the war to thwart Sudan’s civilian-led democratic transition.

Despite the competing narratives of the warring parties, it is the civilian population that has borne the brunt of the conflict. The war has triggered one of the most severe humanitarian crises in the world, displacing 7.9 million people within Sudan and creating over two million refugees in neighboring countries. This section of the research focuses on two main issues:

  1. The nature and patterns of direct violations against civilians.
  2. The impact of these violations on the lives of citizens and related sectors.

The second part of the research (to be published separately) will examine the political and economic motivations behind these violations, the role they play in exacerbating the conflict and humanitarian crisis, and the involvement of external actors supporting the RSF in facilitating these violations. This will provide a deeper understanding of how regional and international dynamics are influencing the situation on the ground.

The research team chose to focus on the violations committed by the RSF due to their significant involvement in perpetrating the majority of violations during the conflict. This is supported by data from the INSIGHTS database, which shows that the RSF was responsible for over 70% of the violent incidents against civilians during the first year of the war. To corroborate this observation, the research team compared the INSIGHTS and ACLED (Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project) databases. According to ACLED, the RSF and its allied militias were responsible for 1,117 incidents of violence against civilians, while the SAF and its allies were responsible for 125 incidents, meaning that RSF violations were approximately nine times more frequent.

INSIGHTS’ database draws on more than 40 open-source materials, the majority of which are Sudanese, including news websites, social media pages of Sudanese grassroots organizations, and independent journalists—INSIGHTS methodology. Additionally, the team incorporated reports and data from international human rights organizations and UN agencies. According to these sources, the violations committed by the SAF were largely limited to indiscriminate shelling in civilian areas and unlawful arrests based on tribal, political, and regional affiliations. In contrast, the RSF and allied militias engaged in a range of grave violations, including extrajudicial killings, torture, systematic rape, slavery, human trafficking, ethnic cleansing, forced displacement, armed robbery, and indiscriminate shelling. Furthermore, the RSF targeted and destroyed vital infrastructure such as banks, health facilities, and the headquarters of civil society organizations, and carried out the complete destruction of several cities and villages in Darfur, displacing their populations.

The U.S. State Department has accused both parties to the conflict of committing war crimes, but has specifically singled out the RSF for crimes against humanity and ethnic cleansing. These findings underscore the need for further investigation into the extensive violations committed by the RSF and their devastating impact on various aspects of civilian life, including food security, infrastructure, education, healthcare, agriculture, and energy.

Research Objectives

The first part of this research seeks to address three main questions:

  1. What are the patterns of violations against civilians in Sudan since the outbreak of the war in April 2023?
  2. What role has the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) played in committing these violations, and how can variations in the frequency and nature of violations be explained using the available data?
  3. How has the ongoing conflict impacted various aspects of life in Sudan, including food security, infrastructure, education, healthcare, agriculture, and the oil sector?

Research Methodology

  1. Primary Data:
    • INSIGHTS Database:
      The primary source of data for this research is the INSIGHTS database, which provides detailed documentation of violations against civilians, including the patterns of violations, the parties responsible, and their geographical distribution across Sudan’s various states and regions.
    • Types Analysis: Data from the INSIGHTS database was analyzed to identify violation patterns and trends. This analysis includes determining the frequency of violations, their temporal and geographical distribution, and identifying the parties responsible for these actions.
    • INSIGHTS Database: The primary source of data for this research is the INSIGHTS database, which provides detailed documentation of violations against civilians, including the patterns of violations, the parties responsible, and their geographical distribution across Sudan’s various states and regions.
    • Types Analysis: Data from the INSIGHTS database was analyzed to identify violation patterns and trends. This analysis includes determining the frequency of violations, their temporal and geographical distribution, and identifying the parties responsible for these actions.
  2. Secondary Data:
    • Reports from International Institutions and Human Rights Organizations: To support and validate the primary data, the research incorporated reports from reputable international organizations and human rights bodies. These reports also helped expand the scope of the analysis to include broader impacts of the war on civilians.
    • News Reports: Neutral and independent news sources were used to supplement the data collection process in order to maintain objectivity.
  3. Analysis Methods:
    • Quantitative and Qualitative Analysis: Both quantitative and qualitative analysis methods were employed to examine the various patterns of violations. This involved analyzing statistical data and numerical trends, as well as investigating specific cases and documented incidents to gain a deeper understanding of the scope and impact of the violations.
    • Spatial and Temporal Comparison: Violations were analyzed across both space and time. This approach facilitates the examination of shifts in patterns and practices in the different states of Sudan.
  4. Documentation and Verification:
    • The data has been rigorously verified through cross-referencing multiple sources to ensure its accuracy. All information has been systematically documented, with a clear emphasis on maintaining transparency in the review process and the sources utilized.

Section One: Overview of Violations Against Civilians During the War

This section provides a comprehensive analysis of violations against civilians in Sudan from April 2023 to April 2024. It examines the nature and distribution of these violations at both state and locality levels, as well as the number of victims affected. The section also evaluates the changes in the frequency of violations over time, including the increase or decrease in the number of deaths during this period. Following this general overview, a detailed analysis will focus specifically on the violations committed by the RSF.

What Does INSIGHTS Data Reveal?

  1. Overview of Violations
Figure (1)

Incidents of violence against civilians are classified into several types: intentional killing of civilians, sexual assault/rape, kidnapping/captivity, torture, physical assault, forced detention, and looting. The data reveal that the most frequent violation against civilians during the first year of the war was intentional killing of civilians, with 358 recorded incidents, followed by looting (281 incidents), physical assault (219 incidents), and forced detention (100 incidents). The least frequent violation was torture, with only 10 incidents documented.

It is important to note that the data is based on the number of events rather than individual victims. For example, a single looting incident may involve multiple victims within a specific location, and a single intentional killing incident may include several victims killed in one incident at a particular location.

More detailed data on the number of victims, particularly in cases of killing, is provided in Figure (2).

Figure (2)

Figure (2) shows the changes in the frequency of violations against civilians and the number of deaths since the beginning of the war in April 2023. Starting in February 2024, the number of deaths has increased, while the frequency of violation incidents has decreased. This indicates that although violations have become less frequent, they have become more violent in nature.

Throughout 2023, the rates of casualties and violations remained relatively stable, except for in June and November. In June, 144 civilians were killed in 39 incidents, and in November, 841 in 36 incidents. These months saw unusually high death tolls in relation to the number of violations, primarily due to massacres committed by the RSF in al-Jeneina on June 15, 2023, (1) and in Ardamata in early November 2023.(2) Figure (2) also reveals a sharp increase in violations against civilians in December 2023, with this upward trend continuing into the first quarter of 2024.

  1. A Deeper Look into the Violations Committed by the RSF

Figure (3)

Figure (3) illustrates the monthly distribution of violations committed by the RSF during the research period, from April 2023 to April 2024. Focusing on the period of increase from December 2023 to April 2024, which accounts for approximately 48% of the total incidents of violence against civilians, we observe that al-Jazeera State stands out as the region most affected by these violations. It experienced a significantly higher number of incidents compared to other states, even when compared to the data from April to November 2023.

Notably, the average number of violations in al-Jazeera during the months from December 2023 to April 2024 was nearly twice as high as the average number of incidents recorded in all other states combined during the earlier period—April to November 2023.

Figure (4)

Figure (4) compares the number of incidents of violence against civilians with the number of deaths in each state from April 2023 to April 2024.

A comparison of Figures (3) and (4) reveals that the nature of RSF violations in al-Jazeera State differed significantly from those in West Darfur. Despite fewer violations in al-Jeneina, the number of deaths there exceeded that of all other states combined during the same period.

When calculating the ratio of victims to incidents of deliberate killings of civilians in al-Jeneina during June 2023, it is observed that, on average, each incident of deliberate killing resulted in approximately 65 deaths. In al-Jazeera State, between December 2023 and April 2024, the average number of deaths per incident of intentional killing is just 2.5. This suggests that while al-Jazeera saw a higher frequency of incidents, these were less deadly compared to those in West Darfur. 

Further supporting this distinction, we note that about half of the physical assaults in al-Jazeera State did not result in death. al-Jazeera recorded 172 incidents of physical assault—the highest number of such incidents in any state. On the other hand, the RSF in al-Jazeera focused heavily on looting, with the state also recording the highest number of looting incidents by a significant margin, totaling 168 incidents during the research period.

Figure (5)

Figure (5) illustrates the distribution of incidents of violence against civilians at localities level from April 2023 to April 2024. A closer analysis of Figures (5) and (6) reveals that al-Jazeera State—following the fall of the SAF garrison—experienced the highest rate of violations against civilians in Wad Madani at the end of 2023.

Within al-Jazeera State, al-Hasahisa locality was the most affected, with 192 recorded incidents. It was followed by South al-Jazeera locality (60 incidents) and Madani al-Kubra locality (55 incidents). In terms of overall incidents, Khartoum State ranked just after al-Jazeera, with a total of 146 incidents during the research period. Within Khartoum State, Khartoum locality recorded the highest number of violations, with 26 incidents, followed by Omdurman, Bahri, and Jabel Awliya localities, each with 19 incidents.

It is important to note that Khartoum State likely experienced a higher number of violations, particularly looting of citizens’ homes. However, due to the nature of the conflict in the state and challenges in verifying incidents, these were not included in the database used for this research.

Figure (6)

Figure (6) shows the number of deaths in each locality from April 2023 to April 2024. 

Looking at Figure (6), we observe that the distribution of victims closely mirrors the distribution of violent incidents: localities with the highest number of incidents also report the highest number of victims. The highest number of deaths occurred in al-Hasahisa locality (209 victims), followed by Madani al-Kubra locality (108 victims), and South al-Jazeera locality (59 victims).

Conversely, al-Jeneina locality in West Darfur recorded the highest number of deaths by a large margin, despite a decrease in the number of incidents there. This supports the earlier analysis regarding the nature and objectives of violations in that area. Additionally, a similar pattern is observed in other localities, such as al-Abbasiya in South Kordofan (101 victims) and Sheikan in North Kordofan (98 victims). The attacks in these areas were notably deadlier.

Violations in al-Jeneina

“The militias systematically targeted people, and killings were carried out based on tribal affiliation. No one was spared—neither women, nor children, nor the elderly.” This testimony, from a witness to the events in al-Jeneina, served as the opening of a United Nations report that extensively detailed the violations committed by the RSF.  (3)

As previously highlighted, the analysis reveals a significant difference in the nature of violations between al-Jeneina and al-Jazeera. In al-Jeneina, the incidents were more violent, with a higher number of victims per incident, compared to al-Jazeera, where although there were more incidents, the violence was less intense.

In an article published on Khatt 30 platform, (4) journalist Aya as-Samani chronicled the story of displaced people (IDPs) from the Masalit tribe, who fled al-Jeneina after the killing of West Darfur Governor Khamis Abdalla Abakar on June 14, 2023. The RSF released videos showing the execution of the governor, who belonged to Masalit tribe, and the mutilation of his body. The targeting of Masalit tribe intensified, initially focusing on the tribe’s leaders and notables, and eventually extending to ordinary members fleeing the city toward Adre camp in Chad.

In her article, as-Samani recounts the testimony of Safia Ishaq Adam, an IDP who had fled al-Jeneina for the Adre camp. She described the checkpoints, referred to as “ambushes,” which posed two critical questions: “Which neighborhood do you live in?” and “To which tribe do you belong?” The answer to these two questions often determined whether a person would be allowed to pass safely or face violence. As Safia explained, “The main purpose of stopping here is not to verify the identity of travelers, but rather anyone identified as Masalit is beaten, humiliated, and may even be killed. Women face physical violence, harassment, and possibly rape.”

In the years preceding the current war, tribal violence in al-Jeneina had already become a frequent occurrence. The last major incident before the war broke out occurred in April 2022 in Kerinek,(5) where more than 200 people were killed. At that time, the conflict was between the Sudanese coalition forces, led by Governor Khamis Abakar, and the RSF, whose soldiers were primarily from Arab tribes.

During these clashes, Musa Mustafa, a member of the Sudanese Coalition, (5) accused the RSF of carrying out ethnic-based executions, an accusation that was reiterated in the 2023 al-Jeneina events. The bloody history of conflicts in this area underscores a persistent pattern of ethnically-motivated violence and systematic targeting by the RSF.

These incidents clearly reflect the tribal nature of the violence in al-Jeneina, which stands in contrast to the violations observed in al-Jazeera and other regions of Sudan. The conflict in al-Jeneina has been ongoing for decades, primarily between Arab tribes and Masalit tribe. Central to the conflict is a longstanding dispute over land ownership. The tensions between Arab (nomads) and Masalit (farmers) began escalating in the 1980s due to territorial disputes. These tensions resulted in the outbreak of the Arab-Fur War in 1987 and later the Arab-Masalit War in 1995. (6)

Several factors contributed to this conflict, beginning with the policies of British colonial rule in Sudan, which denied land and native administration(7) to many Arab tribes while favoring others. This was compounded by severe droughts and desertification in the region since the 1970s, displacement, migration, and the spread of weapons, largely due to the Libyan-Chadian war.(6) The Arab-Masalit War specifically erupted when the Inqaz regime attempted to settle nomadic Arabs in Dar Masalit dividing the area into 13 emirates. Nine of these emirates were allocated to the Arabs, sparking a violent conflict that lasted for four years.(7)

References

  1. Qiblawi, et al. (2023). “Shot at while they drowned. Executed in the desert. Those who collected the bodies recount ‘one of the worst days’ in Darfur’s genocide-scarred history”. CNN. Available at: link (Accessed: 20 July 2024). 
  2. Sudantribune (2023). “RSF Kills over 2,000 civilians in West Darfur’s Ardamata”. Sudan Tribune. Available at: link (Accessed: 20 July 2024).
  3. UN (2024). “مأساة الجنينة، دارفور: “الطرقات مليئة بالجثث والناس يرددون الشهادة استعدادا للموت”. UN News.  CNN. Available at: link  (Accessed: 20 July 2024).
  4. Al-Samani (2023). “موتى وأحياء في الطريق من الجنينة إلى أدري”. Khatt30.  Available at: link (Accessed: 21 July 2024).
  5. Sudantribune (2022). “إتساع رقعة الإقتتال القبلي بغرب دارفور والمعارك تنتقل لمدينة الجنينة”. Sudan Tribune. Available at: link  (Accessed: 21 July 2024).
  6.  د. محمد سليمان محمد (2010). “السودان: حروب الموارد والهوية”
  7. Mamdani (2009). “Saviors and Survivors Darfur Politics and the War on Terror”

Latests Publications

  • All Posts
  • Analytical Articles
  • Data Snapshot
  • Monthly Report
  • Research Papers
  • Special Report